Slip & Falls – Foley v Imperial Oil (Occupiers Duty of Care)

Woman fueling her car - Slip & Falls

Posted In

Slip & Falls

In 2011, the British Columbia Court of Appeal considered the fundamental aspects relating to an injury on property.

The incident occurred at a car wash at an Esso service station in North Vancouver, British Columbia. The injury claimant slipped on a small patch of ice near the car wash and fell backwards hitting his head and suffering a serious dislocation of his right kneecap. There were no warning signs or cones in the area of the car wash exit to warn customers of the risk of ice.

The Court of Appeal found that the owners of the car wash had breached their duty to take reasonable care in the circumstances to ensure that the injury claimant would be reasonably safe in using the car wash. The trial judge also upheld the decision making important comments about the evidentiary burden on occupiers such as gas stations and car washes.

The Court noted that, “The presence or absence of warning signs is a relevant factor when considering liability…in “slip and fall” cases involving the reasonableness of a maintenance program, while the burden of proof rests with a plaintiff to demonstrate that the defendant breached the relevant standard of care, there remains an evidentiary burden on the defendant to rebut any reasonable inferences that might be drawn from the evidence as to whether the defendant has taken reasonable care, in the circumstances, to safeguard the plaintiff who enters onto its property.”

In Ontario too, the law on Occupiers’ Liability has gradually merged from the “rigid rules and formal categories” of the common law that “spawned confusion and injustice”, into the general principles that govern the law of negligence.

Common slip and fall hazards can include, uneven surfaces, buckled carpets, slippery surfaces from liquids or objects, dangerous ice and snow conditions on property, rotten railings and poorly constructed premises and other hidden dangers. If you suffer a slip and fall injury take the following immediate steps at the site of your personal injury:

  • Get immediate medical attention
  • Get the names of witnesses to your slip and fall
  • Take pictures on your phone camera of the site and hazard conditions
  • If possible, take measurements of the area where the injury occurred such as the height differential between sidewalk slabs
  • And contact an experienced personal injury lawyer as soon as possible.

You need experienced legal assistance to ensure you receive fair compensation for your injuries. At Mackesy Smye, our Personal Injury Lawyers are skilled in this special area of personal injury and will guide you through to a successful resolution of your slip and fall claim.

Get started today with a free consultation

Contact us for a complimentary, confidential consultation. Get in touch by filling this secure online contact form or by calling us at 1-905-525-2341 today.

Related Articles

How to Avoid Slips and Falls this Winter (or any time for that matter).

How to Avoid Slip & Fall Accidents

If you’re injured by a third party, what rights do you have? Can you sue for pain and suffering as you would in an auto accident? It’s different for both off-road vehicles and watercraft. In this article, we explain the differences and also give some great advice for staying safe off-road and on the water.

Read Article
personal injuries from slip and falls, slip, trip and falls

Do I Have A Slip & Fall Case?

Victims of a slip and fall accident can seek compensation for medical costs & lost income. Read this post to learn if you have a case. Read this article to better understand slip and fall accidents and what recourse a victim might have and whether there is a case worth pursuing.

Read Article
personal injury, slip and falls - determining liability

Slips, Trips & Falls - Who's Responsible?

If you have tripped, slipped, and had a fall on another person’s property, an experienced personal injury attorney can help you seek the compensation you may be entitled to for your pain and suffering and any other damages that you may have suffered, including loss of income. Read this post to learn more.

Read Article
slip and fall personal injury law

Slips & Falls - The Lawsuit and Litigation Process

If you have suffered injuries from a slip or trip and fall, you may be wondering how long it could take to resolve the matter and claim the compensation you may be entitled to. Depending on a range of factors, it can take anywhere from a few months to several years to resolve. Read this article to learn about the lawsuit litigation process, and know what to expect.

Read Article

Slips, Falls and Long-Term Health Consequences

Unfortunately, slips, trips, and falls are one of the most common forms of personal injury in Ontario. This article discusses the prevalence of slips and falls and the long-term health consequences that victims endure due to these accidents. The good news is that Mackesy Smye Lawyers can help.

Read Article
Man Slipped on Wet Floor - Slip & Falls

Slips and Falls - How is Negligence Defined?

Anyone can trip or have a slip and fall accident in the most unlikely of places. This may be because of poor external conditions, poor premises design or maintenance or a variety of other reasons.

Read Article
Templates Library
Loading, Please wait...
The Library cannot be open, please try it again later.
This field is required.
Invalid email format.
Some of the fields are not filled or invalid.
Form Template
Select a Form Template
Available fields in the selected template: