Steinkrauss v. Afridi – Medical Malpractice

Computer screens in clinic - malpractice

Watching a loved one suffer from a serious illness that has gone untreated or unnoticed by their doctor is a tragedy. An even greater tragedy is having your loved one die from a treatable disease due to such doctor negligence.

In situations of the first kind, patients often decide to undergo civil litigation against the doctor for medical malpractice and negligence, and can ask for punitive damages if the medical professional in question deliberately and consciously neglected or harmed the patient, or attempted to conceal his negligent actions. However, what can be done by the family of the deceased patient in such cases? In one groundbreaking case from Alberta, such a precedent has been set in Steinkrauss v. Afridi.

In this case, the doctor attending Deirdre Steinkrauss was found to have provided sub-par care to his patient by failing to perform genetic testing and the subsequent late diagnosis of her breast cancer. Mrs. Steinkrauss sued Dr. Afridi, but passed away shortly after. During litigation, it was discovered that Dr. Afridi not only failed to live up to the doctor-patient duty of care, but created new medical records to push responsibility for his error from himself onto the patient. While this forgery would certainly have opened Dr. Afridi up to punitive damages had Mrs. Steinkrauss lived, the initial judge ruled that such damages were not awardable to the deceased’s family under the Fatal Accidents Act. Indeed, similar cases in other provinces, particularly Lord v Downer in Ontario, were used to make this ruling.

However, the Appeals Court of Alberta overturned this decision, holding that according to the FAA, it was up to the court to decide which types of damages were appropriate for any given case. This ruling has opened up the possibility of punitive damages to surviving dependents, and could have long-lasting changes in how courts award damages to dependents in civil and class action suits.

The Fatal Accidents Act was originally enacted to allow surviving dependents to recover monetary losses or emotional damages due to the wrongful or preventable death of a loved one – missed wages, health care costs, and pain and suffering experienced, for example. As we’ve previously discussed in how compensation for personal injury claims is calculated blog post, punitive damages are not meant to compensate the dependents for their suffering or tangible loss, but rather to punish the wrongdoer for excessive, flagrant, or obscene actions while causing that suffering. Due to the egregious actions of Dr. Afridi in forging his medical records, the court evidently decided that in this case, the seeking of punitive damages was applicable in this case. And while this clearly opens the door to similar claims in the future, due to the long tradition of rejecting punitive damages, similar rulings will likely be implemented only in similarly extreme cases.

If you believe that a recent court ruling is worthy of appeal, or wish to file medical malpractice or wrongful death suit on behalf of a loved one, use our secure contact form for more information on how we may be of help.

Related Articles

Family Medical Doctor Malpractice in Ontario

Medical Malpractice: Family Doctor Negligence

Proving medical malpractice can be difficult but in cases where a family doctor was negligent in administering healthcare, victims should have their case heard by the courts. Read this post to better understand a family doctor’s duty of care and what constitutes medical malpractice.

Read Article
TBI - traumatic brain injuries & personal injury law

Medical Malpractice & Traumatic Brain Injuries (TBI)

If you or a loved one has suffered a traumatic brain injury while under the care of a medical professional, you need to determine if malpractice occurred. This article offers an in-depth look at Traumatic Brain Injuries (TBI) - click to read more.

Read Article
medical malpractice, personal injury, surgical mistakes

Medical Malpractice - Surgical Negligence

Surgical negligence is not to be taken lightly. We trust medical professionals to take care of us and adequately warn us of risks and complications. We expect them to operate on the correct area of our bodies, and with equipment that is in working order. We trust surgeons with our lives. Read this post to learn more.

Read Article
personal injury law and spinal cord injury

Spinal Cord Injuries & Medical Malpractice

Whether you have suffered a spinal injury as a result of a car accident, an accident at home or another cause, the impact on your and your family’s life can be devastating. When the injury occurs at the hands of a medical professional, it can be particularly devastating. Read this post to learn more.

Read Article
hamilton, ontario medical malpractice suits

Medical Malpractice - Standard of Care in Ontario

If you have sustained injuries or other complications after medical treatment and you have reason to believe that the facility or doctor played a role in your injuries, you may have a case and will need an expert medical negligence lawyer to help. Read this article to learn about the lawsuit litigation process, and know what to expect.

Read Article
Refusing Medical Treatment - Medical Malpractice

Medical Malpractice Cases: Can I Refuse Treatment?

Let us consider this simple scenario: a minivan driver rear-ended Lynn, 46, when she was driving home from her job. After a brief hospital stay, Lynn has chronic low back pain that does not respond to medication.

Read Article
Templates Library
Loading, Please wait...
The Library cannot be open, please try it again later.
This field is required.
Invalid email format.
Some of the fields are not filled or invalid.
Form Template
Select a Form Template
Available fields in the selected template: