The QCIPA, or Quality of Care Information Protection Act, was passed in 2004 with the express intent of allowing those in the healthcare field to speak up about medical errors without compromising patient confidentiality, and, as a result, encourage accountability in the community. This is explicitly stated by the Ontario Ministry of Health, which writes:
The Act promotes the sharing of information and open discussions among health professionals, which can lead to improved patient care and safety. For example, more openness about errors can result in potential solutions to ensure they do not recur.
However, with the tragic suicide of a young man under a Brampton hospital’s psychiatric care, both the hospital and the QCIPA have come under fire as they refuse to disclose the details surrounding the death, even to the man’s immediate family.
While many Canadians take comfort in knowing that their patient records are confidential, some accuse hospitals of misusing the QCIPA to shield themselves from public responsibility. The Act itself trumps The Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act, meaning that interested parties, including families, have no legal avenue for finding out the details of what occurred, in what area the hospital failed the patient, or what practical, corrective steps are being taken.
Some in the medical community, however, argue that the QCIPA itself is not to blame, but rather the hospitals distortion or, at worst, poorly draftedlegislation. One hospital, Toronto East General, reviewed 15 incidents in three years, none under QCIPA, believing that patient privacy protection and hospital transparency are not mutually exclusive. In the same time period, by contrast, University Health Network used QCIPA in all 96 critical incident reviews, with similar results in many Toronto area hospitals.
All this begs the question: who exactly are the hospitals protecting – their patients, or themselves? While the family of the Brampton man continues to search for answers, the province itself is reviewing the Act in the aftermath of the tragedy.
Call us for a free consultation today at 1-905-525-2341 or get in touch through our easy and secure online contact form.
Proving medical malpractice can be difficult but in cases where a family doctor was negligent in administering healthcare, victims should have their case heard by the courts. Read this post to better understand a family doctor’s duty of care and what constitutes medical malpractice.Read Article
If you or a loved one has suffered a traumatic brain injury while under the care of a medical professional, you need to determine if malpractice occurred. This article offers an in-depth look at Traumatic Brain Injuries (TBI) - click to read more.Read Article
Surgical negligence is not to be taken lightly. We trust medical professionals to take care of us and adequately warn us of risks and complications. We expect them to operate on the correct area of our bodies, and with equipment that is in working order. We trust surgeons with our lives. Read this post to learn more.Read Article
Whether you have suffered a spinal injury as a result of a car accident, an accident at home or another cause, the impact on your and your family’s life can be devastating. When the injury occurs at the hands of a medical professional, it can be particularly devastating. Read this post to learn more.Read Article
If you have sustained injuries or other complications after medical treatment and you have reason to believe that the facility or doctor played a role in your injuries, you may have a case and will need an expert medical negligence lawyer to help. Read this article to learn about the lawsuit litigation process, and know what to expect.Read Article
Let us consider this simple scenario: a minivan driver rear-ended Lynn, 46, when she was driving home from her job. After a brief hospital stay, Lynn has chronic low back pain that does not respond to medication.Read Article